Quantcast The Daily Orange
College Media Network

A new generation of gossip | Web site Juice Gossip invokes free speech issues

By Bill McMillan
Posted: 3/28/08, 12:56 AM EST Section: News
  • Print
  • Email
The defamatory statements in question are, in fact, false.

The plaintiff must supply specific language that is defamatory.

The defendant must have specifically identified the plaintiff.

The plaintiff must supply proof that the information in question was published.

Bob Lloyd, a professor of practice for newspaper and magazine journalism, stressed the factors that can make the Internet both an open forum for ideas and a place where users take advantage of online identity.

"In principal, in general, I think that the anonymity of the Internet can be a strength in many cases, but in this case where you post comments about other people without any kind of accountability I think is wrong," he said. "I believe that people ought to stand up and be able attach their name to whatever opinion they have, and to not do that actually borders on cowardice."

While the Internet can be an important source for discussion, Lloyd said, it could also be a place that causes more harm than good.

"I believe that the anonymity that this site will grant someone will prove to be more hurtful than helpful to society," Lloyd said. "It gives you free license to be mean, to be nasty and to say hurtful things that don't actually help society, but actually tear down the social fabric."

Michael Cree, a graduate student in the magazine, newspaper and online journalism program disagreed, saying the site does no more or less good than most others on the Internet.

"I suppose it's just a good a reason for a Web site as any," he said. "It's a bit of fun. I wouldn't really take it particularly seriously. I'm sure if it was completely defamatory in any way, then maybe you'd be wanting to take it down."

Jordan Meddy, a graduate student in broadcast journalism, said Juicy Campus isn't the first of its kind.

"In my undergrad, we had this thing called 'The Gossip Server,' which was basically this Web site where you could just post things anonymously about people," he said. "It was pretty funny."
< prev Page 2 of 3 next >

Article Tools

Be the first to comment on this story

  • NOTE: Email address will not be published

Type your comment below (html not allowed)

  I understand posting spam or other comments that are unrelated to this article will cause my comment to be flagged for deletion and possibly cause my IP address to be permanently banned from this server.





Poll

Will the Syracuse men's basketball team reach the NCAA Tournament this season?

Submit Vote

View Results



Advertisement

Advertisement