Quantcast The Daily Orange
College Media Network

Students protest anti-gay demonstrators on Waverly Avenue

By Amity Paye
Posted: 11/19/09, 1:58 AM EST Section: News
  • Print
  • Email
Media Credit: Will Halsey

Michelle Deferio arrived on Waverly Avenue outside of Newhouse I around 2:30 p.m. Wednesday wearing a long corduroy skirt and holding a sign that read, "Homosexuality is a sin, Christ can set you free."

In response, Chris Pesto, a junior acting major who is gay, made a sign that read "Corduroy skirts are a sin, homosexuals can help you," and stood next to Deferio in protest.

News of Pesto's protest spread. And Michelle and her father, Jim Deferio, who also went to preach to passersby that homosexuality is a sin, soon were facing a crowd of Syracuse University students, protesting against the Deferios, saying SU has no place for hate.

At the peak of the protest, about 60 students turned out. Some had signs, some encouraged passing cars to honk in solidarity for their cause. Although the Deferios only planned to stay on Waverly Avenue for three hours, they did not leave until around 7 p.m. The protestors stayed until 7:30 p.m., when the Department of Public Safety broke them up.

Michelle and Jim Deferio are open-air Evangelists, a religious group that preaches the gospel on city sidewalks, in parks, neighborhoods and on college campuses, among other places. The Deferios frequently preach on Waverly Avenue.

Jim went to school at the State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry and lived on SU's South Campus. Jim said SU has warned him that if he steps on campus he will be arrested, but he said that he is not preaching hate.

Instead, Jim said he is showing love and offering hope. He said, just as he would warn someone if a car were about to hit them, he is warning homosexuals of their sins.

"Love warns people. It would be unloving of me not to warn them," he said. "God is the judge. There are going to be consequences. They can do that, but one day God is going to judge them, just like he will all of us."

To bring hope to the homosexual community, he said, Jim shared experiences he has had with ex-homosexuals to show that change is possible. He said he shared an apartment with one, and has friends who are ex-homosexuals as well. Jim used these examples to support his claim that homosexuality is not genetic, but a choice. He said he has worked for six evangelist organizations in the past but was on Waverly yesterday independently with his daughter.

Just as the Deferios defended their right to preach, they said they were also not against the students' peaceful protest. They had seen many like it before.
Page 1 of 3 next >

Article Tools

Viewing Comments 1 - 10 of 51

Tom Brown

posted 11/19/09 @ 5:54 AM EST

Thank you to the demonstrators who affirmed that the Judaeo-Christian faith is about love and acceptance, not about judgment. The DiFerios may be well-intentioned but by holding up their so-called warning signs, they are driving people away from Christianity. (Continued…)

(1 reply)   Details   Reply to this comment

Allison Gibbons Adams

posted 11/19/09 @ 8:59 AM EST

Having only just graduated, I am so happy to hear that students on my campus are standing up for the rights of their fellows. I wish I could have been there in person, but to all the protesters, know you have solidarity with alumni as well. (Continued…)

Great

posted 11/19/09 @ 9:23 AM EST

Great story. Proud to be an alum.

MM

posted 11/19/09 @ 10:01 AM EST

I've never laughed outloud to any DO article until today. That part about corduroy skirts being a sin was terrific. Not to mention, very true. It's great seeing the students taking on the challenge and speaking out. (Continued…)

Dick Bulova A&S 62

posted 11/19/09 @ 10:12 AM EST

Hopefully, both sides of this issue will learn something helpful from this. Once the protestors began using words like "Bigot" and "Hatred", any possibility for constructive dialog has disappeared. (Continued…)

disappointed in both sides

posted 11/19/09 @ 10:27 AM EST

It will only serve to increase tension between these two communities if the actions of the Deferios are seen as "hateful."

While they seem to lack a sophisticated understanding of the Christian theologies involved, the Deferios *do* represent a large portion of the world population, whom are part of faith traditions in which homosexuality *is* considered a sin. (Continued…)

(2 replies)   Details   Reply to this comment

Proud to have protested

posted 11/19/09 @ 11:36 AM EST

I want to note that we did not leave because we were broken up by DPS but when we were sure DeFerio had left. Students did attempt to talk to DeFerio about his views which I admit I did not do because I do not feel I know enough about the bible to be able to counter his arguments. (Continued…)

MM

posted 11/19/09 @ 11:47 AM EST

@ disappointed

The article notes that Chris Pesto was willing to talk, provided the DiFerio's did not refer to him as a sinner, and that another student did speak with the DiFerios for some time during the demonstration and that she would like to continue the dialog at a later date in a more conducive manner. (Continued…)

drdanfee

posted 11/19/09 @ 11:54 AM EST

Trying to engage in so-called serious critical discussion with the negative, flat earth beliefs that the Deferios still preach about queer folks is (A) not very likely to result in mutual understandings, plus (B) only going to slow down still more, the long occasions wherein the real world facts of gay thriving and citizen competency rub painfully up against the (most often religious?) narratives of dirt, damage, and low life expectations. (Continued…)

David T

posted 11/19/09 @ 12:35 PM EST

I love Christ and his glory. I know God's peaceful plan for me is to be a bisexual man. How can the University better edify a tolerant Central New York?

Post a Comment

  • NOTE: Email address will not be published

Type your comment below (html not allowed)

  I understand posting spam or other comments that are unrelated to this article will cause my comment to be flagged for deletion and possibly cause my IP address to be permanently banned from this server.



Poll

What place will the SU men's team finish in the Big East?

Submit Vote

View Results



Advertisement

Advertisement